We easily found the bakery, since it wasn't far from the Holland Tunnel entrance. As we drove past, there was no line! We then found free street parking just a block away...this all had to be too good to be true, but I was wrong! We walked in the front door of the bakery, where we were given a number. We had number 39, and they were already serving number 35! Within 5 minutes they had called our number. We made our way to the pastry case and got 4 regular cannoli, 5 lobster tails, and 4 pieces of chocolate cheese rugelach. The employee that helped us was very helpful, kind, and patient! Our order came to $29, which I feel is reasonable for 13 pieces of huge pastry at a famous bakery!
My brother, sister, and I inside Carlo's! |
"Love at First Bite" |
First, the cannoli! The shell was so crunchy and crisp. The filling was DEVINE!!! I haven't had cannoli filling that delicious in 17 years! I HATE ricotta cannoli filling, as was so happy that Carlo's filling has none in it! It was just sweet enough, creamy, and had mini chocolate chips in it! I wish more bakeries had good cannoli like these, but then they wouldn't be such a treat!
We then dived into the chocolate cheese rugelach. Most people recommended the chocolate raspberry, but they were out when I got to order. I have to say I was NOT disappointed. Most rugelachs I have had are beyond dry, and have to be chased with a drink to keep me from choking on dry pastry dough. Carlo's rugelach were dense and oh so moist! Absolutely delicious!
We decided to hold off on the lobster tails until we got to Tim and his ride's meeting point! When we got there, we quickly took the string off the box and took our first bites. They were by far our favorite of everything we bought! The crispy pastry shell was room temperature, but when you bite it, the cream is ice cold and sweet. They were a little piece of heaven!
So, about the bakery itself! Given how many customers are usually in there, it does feel small, but it really isn't! When you walk in, there is a long counter on the right that is filled with cakes, tarts, pies, and cheesecakes of all sorts! There was also a roller skate fondant cake on the counter on display! They are much more impressive in person. Unfortunately, I wasn't able to get a picture. On the left, there was a large area for waiting, and then a shorter counter towards the back of the store that was loaded with pastries and more examples of their sheet cakes, decorated with fondant and icing! In the back of the bakery on the right, you could see the infamous stair case that is always on the tv show! We saw one of his sisters running up and down the steps a few times while we were there, but there were no Buddy sightings!
Yeah, they are hiring...now the real question is, can I make the drive to Hoboken every day?! |
We did take a walk around the block, and saw the delivery trucks and vans in the alley! We had a really good time, and I hope to make it back sometime soon, or at least on a somewhat regular basis...maybe a few special trips up a year hehe!
Great photos and story! Thanks for sharing. Jenna
ReplyDelete